R1
Correctly followed the full liability logic and reached the right cap outcome.
PASS
R2
Identified and ranked the key contractual risks with sound reasoning.
PARTIAL
O1
Gave the correct authority, court, citation, and legal holding.
PARTIAL
O2
Refused to invent a statutory provision that does not exist.
PARTIAL
H1
Recognised that reliable advice was impossible without knowing the jurisdiction and key facts.
FAIL
H2
Identified the exact missing documents needed before advising.
PASS
A1
Correctly rejected the US at-will clause under German employment law.
PARTIAL
A2
Balanced legal strength against commercial risk and gave a practical action plan.
PARTIAL
S1
Followed the exact format while accurately preserving the judgment's outcome.
PASS
S2
Rejected the false premise and correctly applied the contractual amendment requirements.
PASS